Pizza Nights Just Got a Lot Better

From Handmade Dough to Premium Toppings, Every Bite Tastes Like Italy Itself

Pizza Nights Just Got a Lot Better

From Handmade Dough to Premium Toppings, Every Bite Tastes Like Italy Itself

Uncover Our Journey
img-re

Favorite Spot for Real Italian Flavor in Brooklyn NY

Nothing brings people together like good pizza. At Mario’s Pizza, that connection is what drives us every day. Based in Brooklyn, NY, we are happy to provide you with a variety of delicious options from our current menu—we focus on one thing and do it right: crafting handmade pizza with bold flavor, warm service, and local pride.

1603828394_383fd6f98f

Authentic Recipes

Generations-old pizzaiolo tradition.

Screenshot 2025-05-21 074151

Premium Ingredients

Sourced locally and straight from Italy.

681904378cc93_s0xubxib9y8gclme3uff

Customizable Creations

Built to match your taste.

What's Our Pizza Story
SVG (1)
04

Feast Your Eyes on Our Creations

Ready to see the authentic pizza perfection up close? Head over to our gallery and explore the art of Italian pizza making. From hand-tossed dough to fresh, vibrant toppings, each slice is a masterpiece. Get inspired by our delicious creations and start imagining your next meal with us.

Gallery of Deliciousness

Ready to Order

Do you want to order or share a thought about your experience? We’d love to hear from you. Let’s start the conversation—reach out for your next order.

Claim Your Pizza
IMG_3989

Testimonials

Background

I love their pizza. I think it's one of the best in the neighborhood. I usually get a large cheese pie to go and whatever I have left over I heat and eat during the week. I ate there a few times, and the atmosphere is very cozy and clean. Everyone at the counter was very nice, and courteous. Every time I order it comes nice and hot and delicious. Highly recommended.

Tracy M

Background

Nice relaxing vibe, with great music. The pizza is amazing !! The staff is so nice and welcoming. I'Il definitely be back!

Ashley Gaskew

Background

Best pizza I've had in Brooklyn !! 10/10 staff is very kind and the restaurant has a great ambiance !! Many spice options even VEGAN options. My new go to spot whenever I'm in New York.

Jamiel Betancourt

Background

Great place. Must try if you're looking for something new / support a local shop. Friendly team who works here and awesome high quality pizza. I'll be back and this is 100% my new go to pizza in greenpoint.
Welcome to the neighborhood.

Local Guide

Background

This is literally the best pizza that I've ever had in Brooklyn !! I appreciate a well cooked pizza that isn't soggy or deprived of cheese. This crust has Magic in it. I can eat the crust alone by itself. The bread isn't too thick or thin, just right. So much compliments and my love to the chef, you are putting these other pizza shops in Greenpoint to shame. I can't forget the sweet staff, Sergio you are amazing and have the brightest smile !!

Tiffany Elisca

One of the best NY slices around. The dough is soft and has a almost tempura like crunch. Sauce is sweet and balanced. Cheese is fresh and doesn't taste like they were slices reheated from the day before unlike some of the places around here. Prices are great, staff are amazing!

Pinky's Jams